Disney's kids' clubs break the mold with their unmatched theming, setting a new standard in the cruise industry. Stepping into these clubs feels like entering a movie set with rooms so realistic and immersive that it transports children into their favorite Disney world. They're truly incredible. From Star Wars adventures to life-sized Toy Story rooms, Disney's creativity knows no limitations. 

Carnival's kids' clubs were a close contender, offering comforting proximity for siblings and exceptional accommodations. Unlike other cruise lines, Carnival provided all parents with a satellite phone for immediate access to their children. Their policy also allowed parents to assist their child in transitioning to the club, a unique feature not found on other lines. If it weren't for Disney's exceptional theming and character visits, Carnival would have taken the top spot for us.

MSC's last-place position is due to several factors. While we appreciated their children's activities and escorted dinners, the kids' club had limited and inconsistent hours. The nursery didn't align with the other kids' club hours, making it challenging to enjoy adult amenities. The staff that week was also restrictive, hindering our toddler's ability to transition and become comfortable. These limitations and inconsistencies made our experience less enjoyable overall.

Disney Cruise Line claimed the top spot in the entertainment and amenities category for several reasons. They are the only cruise line to include 24-hour room service, soda, and quality toiletries in the price of every cruise. Additionally, they offer a variety of ice cream flavors, and all of their shows are family-friendly. It's worth noting, however, that Disney does not offer casinos on their ships, which may be a deal-breaker for some.